Since the dawn of our nation, Pesach has been the one festival that by definition necessitates extensive preparations. Cleaning the home from all chametz (leaven), preparing flour and water worthy of being baked as Matzah and cooking a proper dinner for Seder night are only some of the preparations necessary to celebrate a kosher, joyous, and meaningful Pesach.
But one crucial preparation which has become more essential today more than ever is woven into the fabric of the storytelling of the Exodus on Seder night - by its absence.
The Haggadah (Seder handbook) delineates the order and the methods of how to observe all the obligations of the evening including the mitzvah of retelling the story of our ancestors’ miraculous redemption from Egyptian slavery 3,335 years ago. The story is meant to be told as a response to the child's curious questions about the many changes of the evening: Why are we dipping so much? Why is the bread of choice only Matzah? Why eat bitter herbs tonight? And finally, why is everyone reclining as if they have not a care in the world?
Even if there are no children present at the Seder, the question-and-answer style remains, because even adults must learn and grow, and the Seder is an educational experience for all. In fact, at my family seders, everyone asks the “Four Questions” after the children had their turn because we are all being educated on Seder night.
Based on nuanced differences between the four times the Torah discusses the Seder-night storytelling, the Haggadah defines four types of children (or adults) present at the Seder table.
There is the devout, studious Jew who cares deeply about every detail of the Seder’s proceedings. Another type is negatively triggered by the perceived archaic nature of the service and fails to see its relevance in 2023. Others are just bewildered and simply ask “What’s going on here tonight?” And finally, there are those who are apathetic to the whole spiel and don’t even bother to ask any questions.
We are obligated to respond to every “type” on their level. Teach the scholar everything there is to know about the Seder, and explain the meaning of true spiritual freedom to the rebel in a way that makes it as compelling as ever in 2023. Don’t overwhelm the simpleton with too many details and be sure to engage the guy who can’t wait for the Seder to end.
However, there is a “fifth child” not even mentioned in the Haggadah. In 1957, the Rebbe wrote an urgent public letter alerting world Jewry to the alarming crisis of the “fifth child” growing each year: Jews who are not even showing up to the Seder. The reasons for their absence are irrelevant and we must do everything in our power to bring them to a Seder table.
Why does the Haggadah not mention the fifth child? Because by the time we open the Haggadah on Seder night, it’s too late to arrange for the missing Jews to come. We must work on inspiring them to participate well before the Seder begins.
As your Pesach preparations kick into full gear, please don’t forget to arrange for all your Jewish friends and acquaintances to participate in a Seder on Wednesday evening, April 5.
The Chabad public Seder is open to the entire Jewish community and no one will be turned away due to lack of funds. Please help spread the message and ensure that every Jew in El Paso leaves the category of the “fifth child” and has the opportunity to experience authentic Jewish freedom.